Transfer Station Eyed as Possible Cell Tower Site

About 25 percent of the town has cell service, town officials say, and it's difficult to find land where additional towers could be installed.


Town officials will meet Thursday with a mobile carrier to review yet another possible location for a cell tower in New Canaan.

The site, on the side of a building at the Transfer Station up above Lakeview Cemetery, marks the latest attempt to improve spotty or nonexistent service in large pockets of town—a problem that advocates say affects public safety and quality of life.

The carriers—in this case, AT&T—have been diligent and patient with the town as New Canaan seeks to boost wireless connectivity, according to Geoff Pickard, who oversees the town’s cell service efforts as a volunteer member of the Utilities Commission.

“We know they [carriers] will not fight our battles with neighbors saying ‘I don’t want it [a cell tower] near me,’ ” Pickard told New Canaan Patch. “They have too much to do. It’s up to the town and Utilities Commission to reason with individuals and convince them this town can and needs to grow from 25 percent coverage to 80 percent, and it will not take that many more towers.”

By Pickard’s estimate, five towers are needed to triple connectivity. Notorious dead zones include Ponus Ridge, Smith Ridge especially up toward Vista, NY and southeastern New Canaan.

Though just five towers are needed, New Canaan is running out of options (see video), as proposals supported by some—including local advocates, carriers and state officials—are opposed by others.

Here are some recently thwarted proposals:

  • First Presbyterian Church property (Oenoke Ridge)—Though the tower was to have been installed at a Connecticut Siting Council-approved distance from a church nursery school, some parents opposed the plan.
  • West School (Ponus Ridge)—Verizon had advanced a plan to extend cell service from Aquarion-owned, disused water towers up on Ponus Ridge and progressed to a point with the Board of Education on the idea, until some parents opposed the plan.
  • Route 123 at Country Club Road—It isn’t clear who owns the patch of land at the intersection where there's a tower that officials have eyed for additional equipment to bolster wireless service. In any case, officials at the Country Club of New Canaan would need to come in as stakeholders, and the club hasn't been reachable, Utilities Commission members said at the group’s monthly meeting on Monday.

Pickard said there are other sites in play:

  • Silver Hill Hospital—The psychiatric facility has agreed with T-Mobile to host a tower up behind its main building. That project likely will not be completed until some time in 2014, Pickard said.
  • Norwalk Armory—The property is not in New Canaan but could serve New Canaan residents on Carter Street and other areas well, including Merritt Parkway motorists passing Exit 38.
  • Puddin Hill Road near Route 123—A private homeowner on a 4.5-acre lot has offered to host a cell tower. However, the proposal is facing some opposition from nearby Grace Community Church.

In all cases, a viable proposal to install a cell tower starts with the carriers themselves, who have special maps (a signal generally can go out two miles from a tower) that can show how many new homes would be served by infrastructure. In New Canaan’s case, because lots are generally large and the town’s population is relatively small, the area is not a priority for cellphone companies, Pickard said.

The process is also tedious and time-consuming in the heavily regulated wireless industry—once a site is identified, it requires approval from the state, and on a local level not only is support needed from key stakeholders such as neighbors, but hurdles such as wetlands, deed restrictions and other local planning barriers can arise.

Pickard said he’s hopeful about the Transfer Station.

“AT&T said it’s a good site to put a tower against the building there, it would extend about 50 feet above the building,” he said.

S Dogood February 07, 2013 at 01:48 PM
There is an existing cell tower on 123 just north of country club rd. I do not understand why you would want to add another one within 300 yards of an existing tower?
S Dogood February 07, 2013 at 02:02 PM
You can see the tower on google maps at http://goo.gl/maps/LrZ4L
Michael Dinan (Editor) February 07, 2013 at 03:00 PM
@S Dogood: You are right so let me put a clarification in the article in a second. What the Utilities Commission is looking into is whether carriers not on the existing tower could use it in a way that would improve cell service. At Monday's meeting, commissioners noted that neighbors on the other side of Country Club Road have recommended to the town that the tower itself comes down, so that is also part of what is at issue with that site.
Dave February 07, 2013 at 06:00 PM
You all are dumb do you know that people are dieing more like being murded because there cell didn't have Service or couldn't get a call or text out to be honest the government should jump in and make it Mandatory for these towers and the people who are crying over a cell tower get over your Selves cry cry cry that's all you new Canaan people do is cry about stuff
NCMom February 07, 2013 at 06:53 PM
the current cell service near the transfer station is fine. don't "dump" more stuff on us here with your EMFing new tower's potential health impacts and attendant lower property values please.
Roo22 February 08, 2013 at 05:48 AM
That part of town already gets good cell service. The proposed site at transfer station is much too close to 3 schools and a heavily populated neighborhood filled with young children. The health hazards of having a cell tower that close to so many people is ridiculous! Put it somewhere more rural -- the outskirts of New Canaan are much less dense in population per sq. foot. This is the Worst suggestion to date! It's not whining -- do the research. A rise in cancer, leukemia -- not worth risking everyone's health!
NCMom February 08, 2013 at 05:09 PM
agreed Roo22. That's why it's called EMR -- ElectroMagnetic RADIATION Fields all around these towers!!
Chow mein February 08, 2013 at 06:41 PM
Which cell company wants to build a cell tower where there are no people? A tower might mean one carrier has coverage, but what about the big 3 carriers? I had a mechanical breakdown in New Canaan and I couldn't call for towing service until a homeowner came home and let me use his landline. if this happened in the winter I could have frozen to death.
Ade February 08, 2013 at 07:53 PM
Given the difficulty in finding appropriate tower sites in our town, all cell companies should be forced to share a tower with other carriers.
Laurie Novak February 08, 2013 at 08:35 PM
Please... the transfer station is NOT a viable site.
Craig March 06, 2013 at 06:06 PM
whoever bought a house next to a transfer station, garbage dump and former incinerator knew what they were getting into. give me a break. that place is necessary and ugly so i cell tower is not going to make things worse.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something